Here you'll find some of our top gift picks for Christmas 2023 as well as all time favorites! Most of these items you'll only find here at our store! 


Products 1-48 of 140
Show
11pc Heavens Majesty Divinity Nativity Figure Set
WHILE THEY LAST!
Was: $95.00
Sale: $37.97-$190.00
review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
(5)
Availability: Varies by Selection
Item #: PT14164 -

    Beautiful 11 piece nativity figure set; Divinity Collection with Gold Trimmed Robes; Resin/Stone Mix. Gift Boxed. From the beloved Heaven's Majesty Brand.WITH REMOVABLE JESUS! JESUS IS REMOVABLE FROM THE CRIB!

    28" Heavens Majesty Goat
    Was: $375.00
    Sale: $279.00
    Availability: In Stock
    Item #: 53386 -

      28" Heaven's Majesty Goat (Pairs with #53396 48" Heaven's Majesty Nativity Figures) 28" Goat is made of fiberglass and resin. Suitable for indoor and outdoor use. Perfect piece to add to your 48" or 59" Heaven's Majesty Nativity Set.

      Fontanini 17 Piece Nativity Set with Stable
      Price: $449.95
      Availability: In Stock
      Item #: 34329 -

        17pc Fontanini Figure Set with Italian Stable 5" resin figures, 17" wide wood/moss/bark Italian stable. Story cards and gift box included.

        11pc 8" Heavens Majesty Nativity Figure Set
        WHILE THEY LAST!
        Was: $220.00
        Sale: $88.00
        review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
        (2)
        Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
        Item #: 103591 -

          Beautiful 11 piece nativity figure set; Tallest figure measures 8" tall. Gift Boxed. From the beloved Heaven's Majesty Brand.BONUS: JESUS IS REMOVABLE FROM CRIB!

          11pc 4.5" Heavens Majesty Nativity Figure Set
          WHILE THEY LAST!
          Was: $125.00
          Sale: $49.97
          review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
          (2)
          Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
          Item #: 114624 -

            Beautiful 11 piece nativity figure set; Tallest figure measures 4.5" tall. From the beloved Heaven's Majesty Brand. Resin/Stone Mix. Gift Boxed.JESUS IS REMOVABLE FROM THE CRIB!

            11pc 6" Heavens Majesty Nativity Figure Set
            WHILE THEY LAST!
            Was: $145.00
            Sale: $58.00
            review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
            (3)
            Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
            Item #: 114628 -

              Beautiful 11 piece nativity figure set; Tallest figure measures 6" tall. Resin/Stone Mix. Gift Boxed. From the beloved Heaven's Majesty Brand. JESUS IS REMOVABLE FROM THE CRIB AND CAN EITHER BE SET IN MARY'S ARMS OR IN THE CRIB.

              20" Kneeling Angels Set  statues, church statues, angel statues, hand painted, church goods, church items, christmas statues, easter statues, ZY16145N / ZY16154N
              Was: $495.00
              Sale: $195.00
              Availability: In Stock
              Item #: 53315 -

                20" Kneeling Angels Set2 Angels hand painted, made of fiberglass and resin.

                Battery Operated Advent Taper Candle Set
                Price: $29.95
                review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                (10)
                Availability: In Stock
                Item #: 18868 -

                  A safe, battery operated alternative! Popular 10" LED battery operated advent taper candle set. Set of 3 purple and 1 pink standard sized advent taper candles. These battery operated candles are a bonus for homes where a real flame isn't preferred. Requires 2 'AAA' batteries, not included. FITTING CANDLES TO CANDLE HOLDER TIPS ...

                  Village Scene Nativity Set - 94 Full Colored Pieces
                  Was: $595.00
                  Sale: $395.95
                  Availability: IN-STORE ITEM ONLY; CANNOT BE SHIPPED
                  Item #: 53367 -

                    Village Scene Nativity Set - 94 Full Colored Pieces Complete Nativity village scene features 94 colored pieces. Beautifully detailed Non Movable pieces ranging from Bakers to animals to Shepherds. Set includes Nativity Set, villagers, animals, and back drop. Size - 50" x 15" x 16"

                    19" Heavens Majesty Set of Lambs (3) (for 39" Scale Nativity Figures)  outdoor nativity, indoor nativity, color nativity, 39" Nativity figures, 53398, christmas gift, christmas decor, yard decor, church gift, church items, three kings, wisemen 53376, 53392
                    Was: $325.00
                    Sale: $279.00
                    Availability: In Stock
                    Item #: 53376 -

                      19" Heaven's Majesty Set of Lambs (3) 19" Set of Three Lambs - made of fiberglass and resin. Suitable for indoor and outdoor use. Perfect piece to add to your 39" Heaven's Majesty Nativity Set (#53398)

                      27" Scale Nativity Sheep (Set of 2)
                      Price: $110.95
                      Availability: In Stock
                      Item #: 22918 -

                        27" Scale Nativity Sheep (Set of 2); to add to Joseph's Studio Collection of Fine Nativity Scenes 27" Scale colored sheep from the Joseph's Studio Collection. Set of 2, one standing and one sitting;14.5" tallMaterialsRESIN/STONE MIXDimensions14.5"H X 10.75"W X 4.5"D

                        Advent Wreath with LEGO Bricks
                        Price: $16.95
                        review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                        (1)
                        Availability: In Stock
                        Item #: 113143 -

                          Advent Wreath with LEGO® BricksPrepare your heart for Christmas this year with an advent wreath made out of 48 genuine LEGO® bricks. Build the wreath and candles, then each week of advent “light” a candle with a yellow transparent brick. Remember the rose candle is for the third week!Each candle is made out of several bricks so you can even make them shorter as the weeks of advent go by. This model is not sponsored, authorized or endorsed by the Lego Group. 3" diameter x 1-1/2" tall. Because...

                          Journey To Bethlehem Advent Wreath
                          Price: $59.95
                          review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                          (1)
                          Availability: In Stock
                          Item #: 15694 -

                            Advent wreath depicting the events of that first holy night is crafted of resin with a gold wash finish. Brass candle cups hold the included 10" x 3/4" diameter candles. Ceremony pamphlet also included. Protective rubber feet on bottom. Wreath, 8 1/2" diam. x 2 1/2" high. Color: purple tone FITTING CANDLES TO CANDLE HOLDER TIPS

                            10.5" tall LED Holy Family Nativity Christmas Lantern with continuous confetti swirl motion with the waterglobe effect. Batteries not included. Resin/Plastic; Measures 10.375" tall x 6.75" wide x 3.25" deep. Gift Boxed.
                            Was: $69.95
                            Sale: $59.95
                            Availability: In Stock
                            Item #: 114484 -

                              10.5" tall LED Holy Family Nativity Christmas Lantern with continuous confetti swirl motion with the waterglobe effect. Batteries not included. Resin/Plastic; Measures 10.375" tall x 6.75" wide x 3.25" deep. Gift Boxed.

                              Holy Family Ornament
                              Was: $21.95
                              Sale: $19.95
                              review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                              (1)
                              Availability: In Stock
                              Item #: 04998 -

                                4" Holy Family Ornament from the Joseph's Studio Collection; Resin

                                Jingle Bell Java Coffee
                                Price: $14.99
                                Availability: In Stock
                                Item #: 108899 -

                                  Enjoy the smooth, delicious taste of Mystic Monk Coffee. The Monks strive for perfection in everything they do and each coffee bean is roasted with love and prayer. For many years our most popular flavor, Jingle Bell Java charms the cup with essences of festive spice, white chocolate and bourbon. 12 ounces. Since Mystic Monk's humble beginning, more and more gourmet coffee drinkers have been enjoying the smooth, delicious taste of Mystic Monk Coffee. Most customers become regulars after the...

                                  Kneeling Santa Ornament
                                  Was: $19.95
                                  Sale: $17.95
                                  review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                  (1)
                                  Availability: In Stock
                                  Item #: 18392 -

                                    Kneeling Santa Ornament in Stable with Verse from the Joseph's Studio Collection3.5" tall. Resin/Stone Mix. Verse: That at the name of Jesus every knee should bow" Gift Boxed.

                                    4536 nativity bake set
                                    Price: $16.95
                                    review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                    (2)
                                    Availability: In Stock
                                    Item #: 36627 -

                                      Create a beautiful gingerbread or cookie nativity scene! The 18 piece set includes everything you need to complete the pictured nativity scene. Start a new, meaningful, family tradition and re-use the set year after year. INCLUDES: 18 pieces; Cutters and forms: baby Jesus, Mary, Joseph, 3 Wisemen, camel, ox, sheep, and stable; Icing bag with coupler and tips; Complete recipes, instructions, and tips. Gift Boxed.

                                      Plush Nativity Set for Kids
                                      Price: $34.95
                                      Availability: In Stock
                                      Item #: 121280 -

                                        Plush Nativity Set for KidsGreat Christmas present for a child! 5-piece set. Interactive plush Nativity stable includes Mary, Joseph, Jesus and his manger.Dimension: 9 1/2" x 8 1/2"Material: 100% POLYESTER"For Unto Us A Child Is Born" -Isaiah 9:6 embroidered on front

                                        Story of the Candy Cane Ornament
                                        Price: $12.95
                                        review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                        (1)
                                        Availability: In Stock
                                        Item #: 114899 -

                                          Legend of the Candy Cane OrnamentSolid metal, 3 inch candycane ornament. Adorned with red, green and white epoxy. Gift boxed with Story of the Candy Cane message card.

                                          Wooden Nativity Ornament
                                          Price: $10.95
                                          Availability: In Stock
                                          Item #: 106639 -

                                            Engraved Christmas ornament features a ribbon for hanging. 5" x 2".

                                            5" Fontanini Horse Figure
                                            Price: $40.95
                                            Availability: In Stock
                                            Item #: 35978 -

                                              5" Horse with blanket figure; gift box. Made of polymer.

                                              Nativity Set
                                              Price: $191.95
                                              Availability: In Stock
                                              Item #: 106960 -

                                                Joseph Studio Collection. 7 piece Nativity Set. Set includes Holy Family, Shepherd, and 3 Wisemen. Resin figures vary in size from 3 1/2"-9 1/2".

                                                Blue and Pink 12" Advent Taper Candle Set
                                                Price: $7.95
                                                Availability: In Stock
                                                Item #: 65051 -

                                                  Boxed Set of 3 Blue & 1 Pink; 7/8" diameter taper candles. USA Made, Long Burning. FITTING CANDLES TO CANDLE HOLDER TIPS

                                                  Chocolate Advent Calendar
                                                  Price: $6.95
                                                  Availability: In Stock
                                                  Item #: 16766 -

                                                    Prepare for Christmas by opening a window each day during Advent to reveal a special picture and a piece of premium imported milk chocolate. Advent calendar contains 2.6 ounces of chocolate. 10"x 13 3/4". 2.6 oz. (75g) premium milk chocolateBible text following the story of the Nativity This item does not contain peanuts or tree nuts as ingredients, and is not manufactured on equipment or in a facility that processes peanuts or tree nuts. This item contains milk and soy. ...

                                                    Christmas In Heaven Gift Boxed Chime
                                                    Price: $19.95
                                                    Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                    Item #: 119147 -

                                                      Our Gift Boxed Chimes are comprised of metal and high quality glass crystals. The box features a printed sentiment. Gift Box Measures: 8.5"L x 5.25"W x .75"D Chime Measures: 10.75"L x 2.5"WSentiment Card Reads, "Christmas In Heaven - What do they do? They come down to earth to spend it with you. So save them a seat, just one empty chair, you may not see them, but they will be there."

                                                      Gold Shimmer Nativity Set, 6 Figures, Resin
                                                      Price: $44.95
                                                      Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                      Item #: 119669 -

                                                        8" scale figures

                                                        Hand Painted Baby Jesus Lying in Manger Shelf Sitter
                                                        Price: $11.95
                                                        Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                        Item #: 118289 -

                                                          Hand-painted wood baby Jesus manger scene shelf sitter with raised painted scene of baby Jesus lying in a manger with a star hanging from above.9"H x 3.25"W x 1"D

                                                          Jewel Tone 6 Piece 5.75" Nativity Figure Set
                                                          Price: $64.95
                                                          Availability: In Stock
                                                          Item #: 118733 -

                                                            5.75" JEWEL TONE NATIVITY Set of 6Made of Resin

                                                            Kneeling Santa in Bag
                                                            Price: $9.95
                                                            Availability: In Stock
                                                            Item #: 19181 -

                                                              'Keep Christ in Christmas' Small Kneeling Santa Statue in Pouch. Resin/Stone Mix

                                                              The Christmas Cross Lapel Pin
                                                              Price: $16.95
                                                              Availability: In Stock
                                                              Item #: 116430 -

                                                                The Christmas Cross Lapel Pin 2.5" with colored rhinestones; Carded with story card The Christmas Cross Tree celebrates the promise of Jesus. His birth is symbolized by the Christmas Tree and yet upon another tree, the cross, came His death with the promise of eternal life. The five stones are for the wounds He bore. Wear this lapel pin to serve as a reminder of all Christ did for us.

                                                                Think of Me at Christmas Bookmark
                                                                Price: $1.95
                                                                Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                Item #: 06909 -

                                                                  2 1/2" X 7" Laminated bookmark

                                                                  14" Winter Frost Advent Wreath
                                                                  WHILE THEY LAST!
                                                                  Was: $34.95
                                                                  Sale: $29.99
                                                                  Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                  Item #: 114172 -

                                                                    Winter Frost Advent WreathBeautiful silver accented advent candleholder which holds four standard taper candles, not included. 12" diameter. Comes gift boxed.FITTING CANDLES TO CANDLE HOLDER TIPS

                                                                    22" Marine Grade Outdoor Nativity Camel *WHILE SUPPLIES LAST* ti50, outdoor decor, outdoor nativity, pvc nativity, complete nativity, animal nativity, camel nativity, yard nativity, 202632-30008
                                                                    WHILE THEY LAST!
                                                                    Was: $124.95
                                                                    Sale: $89.95
                                                                    Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                    Item #: 21564 -

                                                                      Beautiful silhouette style outdoor nativity Camel that complements any yard. The camel is constructed of 1/2" marine grade plastic sheet that cannot rot or delaminate and never requires painting. Measure 22" Tall x 41" Wide x 1/2" Thick when assembled. Quick and simple assembly. Simply locate your stake and slide your camel on. Show off the reason for the season with this classic outdoor nativity set. This size matches the #20545 nativity set CLICK HERE FOR ADDITIONAL PIECES ...

                                                                      6.25" Kneeling Santa with Tree Figurine
                                                                      Price: $22.95
                                                                      Availability: In Stock
                                                                      Item #: 114506 -

                                                                        Description6.25" KNEELING SANTA FIGURINE WITH CHRISTMAS TREETHIN STYLE/WAFER DESIGNThemeKNEELING SANTADivisionJOSEPH STUDIOMaterialsRESIN/STONE MIXDimensions6.25"H 4"W 1.75"D ...

                                                                        7-Piece African American Nativity Set
                                                                        Price: $69.95
                                                                        review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                                                        (2)
                                                                        Availability: In Stock
                                                                        Item #: 116908 -

                                                                          7 Piece African American Nativity Set Catholic Supply is pleased to offer and expertly crafted, seven piece black nativity scene. A response to widespread demand, the set includes seven full size figurines including detailed representations of baby Jesus, Mary, Joseph, the three wise men and lamb. An excellent Black Gift idea, this beautiful African American nativity set is sure to be the perfect addition to any Christmas décor. A. 1.75”W x 1.6”D x 6”HB. 2.25”W x 1.6”D x 5.8”HC. 3”W x 3.25”D x...

                                                                          Assorted 19" White Angel Statues with Metal Wings, Sold Each
                                                                          WHILE THEY LAST!
                                                                          Price: $62.95
                                                                          review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                                                          (1)
                                                                          Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                          Item #: 118284 -

                                                                            Hand-painted resin angel figurines. Angels wear set white robes and have brown hair and detachable metal wings. These come in assorted styles as shown. If you have a preference, stop into our store. Styles are available while supplies last only. If ordering online, please allow us to select for you.19"H x 15"W x 4.5"D

                                                                            Assorted 7" Clip On Cardinal Ornaments, Sold Each
                                                                            Price: $4.95
                                                                            review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                                                            (1)
                                                                            Availability: In Stock
                                                                            Item #: 118692 -

                                                                              7" CLIP-ON CARDINAL ORNAMENT Made of Foam and Feathers

                                                                              Blessing Angel at Christmas Figurine
                                                                              Price: $16.95
                                                                              Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                              Item #: 119146 -

                                                                                Our gift boxed angels are made of hand-painted resin. Each gift box comes complete with a sentiment card and velvet lining for protection. The angel measures 3"H x 2"W x 2"D and the gift box measures 4.25"H x 5.25"W x 2.25"DSentiment Card Reads, "Blessings of peace, hope and love to you and yours this Christmas season."

                                                                                Cardinals in Snow LED Lantern
                                                                                Price: $29.95
                                                                                Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                                Item #: 119437 -

                                                                                  Our lanterns are made of weather friendly materials and UV printed glass. They include a flameless LED candle with a built-in automatic timer: 6hrs ON/18hrs OFF (3 AAA batteries are NOT included). They are suitable for hanging or free-standing use. W: 5.5"H: 13"D: 5.5"

                                                                                  Chocolate Advent Calendar
                                                                                  QTY DISCOUNTS
                                                                                  Price: $6.95
                                                                                  review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                                                                  (3)
                                                                                  Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                                  Item #: 116340 -

                                                                                    Prepare for Christmas by opening a window each day during Advent to reveal a special picture, Bible Text and a piece of premium imported milk chocolate. Advent calendar contains 2.6 ounces of premium milk chocolate. 10" x 13 3/4". Bible text following the story of the Nativity. 2.65 oz. Premium Milk Chocolate | Bible Text on Back of Windows | 10" x 13 3/4" | Made in CanadaThis item does not contain peanuts or tree nuts as ingredients, and is not manufactured on equipment or in a facility that...

                                                                                    Mystic Monk Christmas Blend Ground Coffee
                                                                                    Price: $14.99
                                                                                    Availability: In Stock
                                                                                    Item #: 113174 -

                                                                                      Mystic Monk Christmas Blend Ground Coffee | The pinnacle of our non-flavored coffees, Christmas Blend 2018 is made with beans from all over the world, including a special Ethiopian Yirgacheffe, Burundi and more. Your whole family will enjoy the festive notes of citrus and blueberry, and smooth malt-toned chocolate aftertaste. 12 ounces Since Mystic Monk's humble beginning, more and more gourmet coffee drinkers have been enjoying the smooth, delicious taste of Mystic Monk Coffee. Most customers...

                                                                                      Comfort Angel at Christmas Figurine
                                                                                      Price: $16.95
                                                                                      Availability: LOW STOCK - ACT FAST
                                                                                      Item #: 119144 -

                                                                                        Our gift boxed angels are made of hand-painted resin. Each gift box comes complete with a sentiment card and velvet lining for protection. The angel measures 3"H x 2"W x 2"D and the gift box measures 4.25"H x 5.25"W x 2.25"DSentiment Card Reads, "May you take comfort in knowing that angels are watching over you this holiday season."

                                                                                        Heavens Majesty Mallard 16" Tall (for 39" Scale Nativity Figures)
                                                                                        Was: $79.95
                                                                                        Sale: $59.95
                                                                                        Availability: In Stock
                                                                                        Item #: 53378 -

                                                                                          Painted resin. 28.5" tall standing, 21" tall kneeling.Wi16" Heaven's Majesty Mallard (Pairs with #53398 39" Heaven's Majesty Nativity Figures) 16" Heaven's Majesty Mallard - made of fiberglass and resin. Suitable for indoor and outdoor use. Perfect piece to add to your 39" Heaven's Majesty Nativity Set (#53398) ...

                                                                                          8" Holy Family
                                                                                          Price: $35.95
                                                                                          review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                                                                          (1)
                                                                                          Availability: In Stock
                                                                                          Item #: 102311 -

                                                                                            Joseph Studio wood carved look 8' figure. Resin figure and full color.

                                                                                            Irish Blessing Ornament
                                                                                            Price: $16.95
                                                                                            Availability: In Stock
                                                                                            Item #: 117473 -

                                                                                              2.75" pewter ornament features sparkling green enamel; window boxed with message as shown.

                                                                                              Irish Claddaugh Ornament
                                                                                              Price: $8.95
                                                                                              Availability: In Stock
                                                                                              Item #: 28390 -

                                                                                                This Irish Claddagh Shaped Ornament has the words "Friendship, Loyalty, Love " on the ornament. Green ribbon for hanging. Made of pewter

                                                                                                Kneeling Santa Statue
                                                                                                Price: $125.95
                                                                                                review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
                                                                                                (1)
                                                                                                Availability: In Stock
                                                                                                Item #: 18899 -

                                                                                                  From the popular Joseph Studio Collection! 13" tall. Resin/Stone Mix.